Sight: SHORTLISTED FOR THE WOMEN'S PRIZE FOR FICTION 2018

von Jessie Greengrass 
3,0 Sterne bei2 Bewertungen
Sight: SHORTLISTED FOR THE WOMEN'S PRIZE FOR FICTION 2018
Bestellen bei:

Neue Kurzmeinungen

Kathycaughtfires avatar

Dieses Buch hat definitiv seine Berechtigung, so richtig ergriffen hat es mich aber leider einfach nicht.

Alle 2 Bewertungen lesen

Auf der Suche nach deinem neuen Lieblingsbuch? Melde dich bei LovelyBooks an, entdecke neuen Lesestoff und aufregende Buchaktionen.

Buchdetails

Aktuelle Ausgabe
ISBN:9781473652378
Sprache:Englisch
Ausgabe:Fester Einband
Umfang:208 Seiten
Verlag:John Murray
Erscheinungsdatum:22.02.2018

Rezensionen und Bewertungen

Neu
3 Sterne
Filtern:
  • 5 Sterne0
  • 4 Sterne0
  • 3 Sterne2
  • 2 Sterne0
  • 1 Stern0
  • Sortieren:
    miss_mesmerizeds avatar
    miss_mesmerizedvor 5 Monaten
    Jessie Greengrass - Sight

    When is the best moment to have a child? Can you ever be ready to become a parent? And what does being a “good” parent actually mean? Jessie Greengrass unnamed narrator has to face these questions. Her husbands would like to have children, she is unsure. Her own childhood comes to her mind, her mother and grandmother, the way they treated her when she was a child, their complex family relationships and the fact that neither her mother not her grandmother is still alive. Yet, families and relationships are never easy, thus, Röntgen and Freud come to her mind as well as the beginnings of modern child birth.

    Jessie Greengrass debut novel directly made it to the short list of the 2018 Women’s Prize for Fiction. It is an unexpected and uncommon combination of medical history, on the one hand, and a very personal reflection on the narrator’s own life and her feelings about motherhood. It starts with the narrator confronted with the essential question of becoming a mother or not when suddenly her rumination is interrupted by the report about Röntgen. Again and again, these two perspectives alternate which is interesting, but also difficult to follow since it often seems to lack a red thread. They are not isolated accounts, she cleverly combines the topics, e.g. her grandmother was a psychoanalyst like Freud, to give a reason for these interludes.

    I can see why the novel made it to the Women’s Prize for Fiction’s short list. The topic tackles a core question of human beings and a deep wish we all share: knowing something for sure, being able to use medical precision for personal decisions and knowing that you do the right thing. Being able to look at something from a neutral and objective point of view, analysing and then making a decision – that’s what we often wish for, however, that’s not how life works.

    Contradictory emotions, uncertainty – a lot of apparent opposites come together in the novel. Even though I found the narrator’s thoughts often easy to following and from a topical point of view most interesting, the novel as a whole did not completely convince me. I would have liked to stick with the narrator’s thoughts. Maybe it was all a bit too philosophical for my understanding. 

    Kommentieren0
    2
    Teilen
    Kathycaughtfires avatar
    Kathycaughtfirevor 3 Monaten
    Kurzmeinung: Dieses Buch hat definitiv seine Berechtigung, so richtig ergriffen hat es mich aber leider einfach nicht.
    Kommentieren0

    Gespräche aus der Community zum Buch

    Neu

    Starte mit "Neu" die erste Leserunde, Buchverlosung oder das erste Thema.

    Was ist LovelyBooks?

    Über Bücher redet man gerne, empfiehlt sie seinen Freunden und Bekannten oder kritisiert sie, wenn sie einem nicht gefallen haben. LovelyBooks ist der Ort im Internet, an dem all das möglich ist - die Heimat für Buchliebhaber und Lesebegeisterte. Schön, dass du hier bist!

    Mehr Infos

    Buchliebe für dein Mailpostfach

    Hol dir mehr von LovelyBooks